Race was costly in the 2nd District

At $3.96 million, it was only Utah's 4th priciest

Published: Tuesday, Feb. 1, 2005 12:36 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — While democracy is supposed to be about the free exchange of ideas, there was nothing free about the campaign for Utah's 2nd Congressional District.

Candidates — mostly incumbent Democrat Jim Matheson and GOP challenger John Swallow — combined to spend a whisper less than $4 million, according to federal campaign disclosures due Monday.

But the $3.96 million spent was only the fourth most expensive House race in Utah history, well behind the $4.8 million spent in 2000 when Matheson first won the seat against businessman Derek Smith.

The 2004 total was slightly behind the 1994 total of $4.04 million when Republican Enid Greene won in a three-way contest with Karen Shepherd and Merrill Cook, and the 2002 total of $4.03 million when Swallow first challenged Matheson.

At least those are the "official" numbers reported to the Federal Election Commission. Unofficially, close to another $2 million was spent on behalf of the candidates but without coordination with the candidate's campaign — bringing the total to somewhere between $5 million and $6 million, or the most expensive House campaign in Utah history.

Story continues below

According to official candidate reports filed with the FEC, Matheson raised $1.97 million to go with another $121,000 in cash to start the campaign, and he spent just over $2 million on his re-election bid.

His GOP challenger, Swallow, raised $1.48 million and spent $1.47 million.

Swallow's totals included fund raising and expenses associated with a tight primary election against businessman Tim Bridgewater, who spent $439,189 on his rematch with Swallow that followed a narrow loss to Swallow in 2002.

A third Republican contender, Salt Lake Councilman David Wilde, spent $28,000 before being eliminated at the state GOP convention last April.

The bitterly contested general election race featured an unusual amount of negative advertising — at least unusual by Utah standards — and it even resulted in complaints filed with the FEC that Republicans had violated federal election laws.

In one of the most bizarre twists of the campaign, a Republican mailer attacked Matheson for supporting the "Dream Act" whereby children of illegal immigrants would be eligible for college tuition. But the bill was actually co-sponsored by Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, and Rep. Chris Cannon, R-Utah.

With the help of fellow Democrats in Congress and a wealth of PAC money that typically goes to incumbents, Matheson was able to raise more than a half million dollars more than Swallow, and he spent that much more than Swallow and a little more.

Most of Matheson's money — 63.3 percent — came from PACs and political committees, whereas only 36.7 percent was contributions from individuals.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Restaurant destroyed by fire

stacy, have you ever eaten there ??

I had Brother Pratt at Viewmont High School my sophomore year... I was really...

Millsap a backup in Portland? That's possible. But think about it, the...

Go Utes! Looks like the tdn are shaping up to have better than MUSS...

We are all inocent until proven GUILTY in this country. We cannot judge the...

Both of these players were looking at BS!!! It's too bad that the Utes are...

Keep one thing in mind as we all cast our ill informed opinions in here -...

Jazz brass debate Millsap match

I think 8 to 9 million is too steep for Milsap, especially since we'll have...

you know all the non believers from the south can say all they want, really...

Independent of the outcome of this investigation, these serious allegations...

Advertisements