'Loser-pays' bill slammed
Making loser in civil suit cover attorney's fees called harmful
But SB92 sponsor Sen. David Thomas, R-South Weber, said his bill would shut down frivolous lawsuits, telling fellow members of the Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Standing Committee this past week that the bill would create real consequences for people who use the courts for intimidation or extortion.
"Loser-pays works in a more positive way more often than not," Thomas said, pointing out that Europe has a loser-pays system, as does the state of Alaska. Thomas said the bill would also help to make Utah "more business friendly."
However, some attorneys told the committee that such a change would shift interest in courts away from winning on the merits of a case to winning for the sake of attorney's fees.
"It's ultimately harmful to people," said Roger Hoole, vice president of the Utah Trial Lawyers Association. Hoole said Utah has no real problem with a flood of frivolous suits but said SB92 could actually end up creating a "cottage industry" of litigation for the sake of going after attorney fees.
John Fay, trial lawyers association president, said the result would be attorneys filing more motions, challenging whether or not awarded attorney's fees were reasonable, creating more work for judges. Under current law, attorneys can ask a judge for an award of attorney's fees, but it is not automatically awarded.
John Nielsen, a lobbyist with the Utah State Bar, said the bill could also discourage lower-income people from suing large companies for threat of having to pay huge sums in attorney's fees should they lose. Representatives with the insurance industry also expressed concern that the bill would cause more work for courts.
Other citizens testified against the bill. Other than Thomas, no one testified in favor of the bill.
Assistant State Court Administrator Rick Schwermer said the courts would not take a position on the bill, but judging from the bill's language, Schwermer estimated the decrease in frivolous suits would be balanced out with increases in motions over attorney's fees. "Workload-wise it would be close to a wash," Schwermer said later.
Committee member Sen. Patrice Arent, D-South Cottonwood, said although she applauded Thomas' goal to limit frivolous suits, she had real concerns about the bill's unintended effects.
Sen. Gregory Bell, R-Fruit Heights, said the bill illustrated the frustration attorneys have had on judges' reluctance to award attorney fees in civil cases.
Committee members passed the bill with a favorable recommendation, with Arent voting against. Thomas agreed to rework the bill to address concerns before taking it to the Senate floor for debate.
E-MAIL: gfattah@desnews.com
Comments
- Funds for new courthouse approved 1:48 a.m.
- Godfrey vetoes Ogden budget 1:48 a.m.
- Odd Fellows Hall move 1:47 a.m.
- 2 country groups to perform 1:47 a.m.
- Rumor has Boozer with Bulls 1:20 a.m.
- Jazz in back of line for free agents 1:19 a.m.
- Okur signs two-year extension 1:18 a.m.
- Marion to Mavs, Stackhouse to Griz 1:16 a.m.
- Price for redistricting plan challenged 1:04 a.m.
- Basketball campers learn service 1:02 a.m.
- Rumor has Boozer with Bulls
- Stadium of Fire flag burning was fake
- Okur signs two-year extension
- Jazz in back of line for free agents
- Restaurant destroyed by fire
- A primer for the 6th Potter film
- Jazz won't meet Lopez on Europe trip
- Blazers may offer Millsap a contract
- MWC, WAC rushed into BCS
- 'The Story of R.C. Willey'
- Bronco collecting a galaxy of recruits
138 - Letters: Palin mistreated
136 - Teachers struggle with district cuts
134 - Blazers may offer Millsap a contract
122 - Rumor has Boozer with Bulls
82 - Fairness of BCS debated
81 - Moon landing: Let's hear from you
73 - Chaffetz eyes challenging Bennett
72 - Services bids farewell to Jackson
70 - Letters: Time for a revolution
69
Through the years, I've always raised eyebrows whenever I tell people...
Sen. Scott Jenkins was name-checked by Jay Leno Monday night during his...
Blazers get the unbalanced trade they seek while not signing Millsap away...
Ricky Bobby - THE JAZZ DO NOT WANT TO TAKE BACK EQUAL SALARIES. They want to...
Despite the fact that logging has all but stopped in the pacific northwest...
My understanding of what FAIR is trying to do, is to provide well thought out...
Jazz will resign Milsap. If they don't it will be ahuge mistake. First off,...
I was waiting for it to be burned on the big metal structure right by the...
Hey Ute fan... the Utes had a good season. And keep throwing that BCS bowl...
Tyrus Thomas is in the last year of his contract too so what is the point for...
CougarKeith, people don't know how to properly retire the flag, what they did...
It is just talk but since it was brought up: IF we can get Prizbilla &...



You can be the first to comment on this story.