From Deseret News archives:
Medical choice bill could lower or raise costs
Committee passes SB34 but wants data on its fiscal impact
While there was little debate during Thursday's Senate Business and Labor Committee meeting about whether access to doctors who are not part of a health management organization's plan would improve if SB34 passes the Legislature even opponents of the bill called it a "freedom of choice" bill there was plenty of ammunition from both sides about how the law would affect costs.
What there was not, however, was a fiscal note on the bill from legislative analysts, a problem for at least some of the committee members who asked that it be held until a note is prepared. Should the bill have a significant fiscal impact, either on the state or on individuals and businesses, even supporters conceded it would have a hard time passing the Senate.
"The fiscal note will tell us the story about whether costs are going up or down," Sen. Bill Hickman, R-St. George, said. "Personally, I believe it's going to increase costs. It may give more access, but costs will rise."
SB34 would allow patients to go to a doctor outside of the insurance provider or health management organization by requiring that the outside doctor be reimbursed at 95 percent of what a plan doctor would have been paid. Buttars said that would have the dual benefit of giving patients the freedom to choose their medical provider without costing the insurance provider any additional money.
Buttars also said that it only makes sense for rates to drop if patients have their choice of doctors.
"If you believe that competition will raise prices, then vote against this," he said.
Opponents of the bill, which included insurance companies, small business representatives and advocates for low-income families, told a different story, however. If patients are allowed to go outside of the plan, then doctors in the plan will have to charge more because they will have fewer patients, which would raise insurance rates and potentially force smaller HMOs out of the state, they said.
"If we can't drive membership to hospitals, we can't offer discounted rates," said Kirk Olsen, the chief executive officer of Molina Health Care of Utah. "That will hurt all of us . . . it will not increase competition, it will decrease competition."
Throughout the almost two hours of public testimony and committee debate Thursday, both sides the approximately 150 people packed into the committee room seemed almost evenly split between those for and against the bill presented a slew of statistics, cited studies and told personal stories to support their position. By the end of the meeting, even those who voted in favor of the bill were hedging their support.
"This issue needs further debate," Sen. Ed Mayne, D-West Valley, said. "I'm supporting it so it can get to the Senate floor for that debate, but there are some things that concern me."
E-mail: jloftin@desnews.com
Comments
- Cops need help in tool heist 7:08 p.m.
- Source says Flyers fire Stevens 7:07 p.m.
- Murder case starts for juvenile 6:46 p.m.
- Court decision could cost $15M 6:44 p.m.
- West Bountiful fire displaces three 6:25 p.m.
- Ed Smart infuriated with revelations 6:24 p.m.
- Opposition to soccer complex 6:17 p.m.
- Brokaw unhurt in crash 6:16 p.m.
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing 6:14 p.m.
- Higher school math requirements? 6:13 p.m.
- Mr. Football 2009: Tuni Kanuch
- Ed Smart infuriated with revelations
- 5A high school football All-State
- Miller predicted Tiger's rough road
- Utah Jazz going green with unis
- 4A high school football: All-State
- Harpring's NBA career is over
- Nutty Putty Cave to be sealed today
- MVPs wrap up stellar prep careers
- Jazz: Miles, Kirilenko to play Friday
- Hall reprimanded by MWC
408 - Max Hall issues apology
393 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
362 - Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?
293 - Utes won't respond to Hall
278 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
247 - Letters: Liberal because LDS
233 - 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
189 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
183 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
179
First, a big thank you to all who posted questions here for me to ask...
Sen. Scott Jenkins was name-checked by Jay Leno Monday night during his...
I agree...don't really care which of these three annoying teams win this...
About time! School should be more rigorous, not less. Twelfth grade in this...
I know the wonderful couple who were leasing that house from the Coopers....
It is exactly on point, just throw out ideas on intuition - prove them later....
I don't live in Utah anymore and it's refreshing not to be in the middle of...
Moderation in all things? Does that mean we should be moderate politically?...
Lock Skeem in a cell with Mitchell for 50 years and see what happens.
Yes it has grown on some people and run over some people. It is still...
The guy ringing the fire bell usually doesn't have the answers. He just...
HI MY DAD WAS BIT BY MY GRAND-PARENTS CAT 3 DAYS AGO, BETWEEN HIS THUMB AND...




You can be the first to comment on this story.