From Deseret News archives:

Who should defend Utah ban on gay marriage?

Walker says AG's office; Buttars says otherwise

Published: Friday, Nov. 19, 2004 9:07 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Gov. Olene Walker said Thursday that the attorney general's office should defend Utah against any legal challenges to the new anti-gay-marriage amendment to the state constitution.

But Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, who wants the state to hire outside counsel in the event of a lawsuit because of Attorney General Mark Shurtleff's opposition to the amendment, said he was not swayed by the governor.

Buttars told the Deseret Morning News there's a "50-50 chance" that lawmakers will come up with a bill next session that will allow them to choose the attorneys that represent the state without consulting the attorney general's office.

Meanwhile, two attorneys who supported the Utah campaign for the constitutional ban said Thursday that a new nonprofit corporation, the Marriage Law Foundation, is willing to do just that by offering legal advice nationwide in efforts to ban same-sex marriage. Monte Stewart and Bill Duncan said they and the foundation will work with like-minded groups to defend the traditional concept of marriage.

"Since the election, Bill Duncan and I have fielded telephone calls daily from around the country, which brought home even more forcefully the need for the Marriage Law Foundation," Stewart said.

Story continues below
During the taping of her monthly televised press conference on KUED Ch. 7, Walker that the attorney general's office should be able to handle any lawsuits filed now that Amendment 3 has been approved by voters.

"We have a very well qualified attorney general's office," Walker said. "It's the largest law firm in the state of Utah. I certainly think that within that law firm, within the state attorney general's office, there is the capability of handling it."

Gov.-elect Jon Huntsman Jr. shares that view, said his chief of staff, Jason Chaffetz.

"We agree with the governor on that," Chaffetz said. "This is clearly the responsibility of the attorney general, and we believe he should be representing the state on this issue."

Shurtleff said he appreciated the support. "There are only a couple out there who don't feel that way," he said, promising to "continue to try to work" with them. The attorney general said he will meet next week with Buttars.

"There've been some strong feelings, obviously. . . . I still think the best way is for our office to handle it," Shurtleff said. "We're moving on. There's not going to be any retribution or retaliation."

Heated issue

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Just in case no one else is watching, gold broke through the $1200/oz barrier...

Assuming that the prosecutor is following the law, it is investigations like...

Now there is no wasted time or money in a prolonged trial and jail time. No...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

Isn't there a psychological term called projecting? Isn't that where you...

As evidenced by the posts here, the BYU kitten fans do not feel like the...

Holiday candy is a poor comparison to what few natural sites there are for...

Old Joe Smith and Max Hall had a lot in common: "...and while they were...

I was shocked by the '0-to-5' year term until I read that the "victims" had...

Billions more for war. What on earth for? What a waste of financial...

6 sons soar as Eagle Scouts

Awesome story! Way to go to this outstanding family.

Advertisements