From Deseret News archives:

'Nanny 911' exploits kids

Published: Tuesday, Nov. 2, 2004 1:52 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
When it comes to so-called "reality" shows, I don't really care what adults do. If grown-ups decide to sign on to one of these things and make themselves look like fools, well, that's their right.

And, besides, you don't have to watch it.

If, on the other hand, kids end up participating in TV's version of "reality," that's a different story. Which is why I have serious problems with the new Fox series "Nanny 911."

The premise is that parents whose children are out of control call on an experienced nanny to come in and help them out. So perhaps I should be grateful that nobody's having plastic surgery to become a "Swan" or being there "When Animals Attack," like your average Fox reality show. And, frankly, there's nothing particularly original about this idea — "20/20" has done segments that look exactly like this.

But these are real, live kids they're talking about when the show opens to this narration: "They are every parent's worst nightmare. Kids completely out of control and taking over the household. These families have reached the end of the rope. They are in desperate need of help. They only have one alternative left — time to dial 'Nanny 911.'"

Excuse me, but there's no alternative to putting your kids on TV for the entertainment purposes of others? (And to feed Fox's bottom line?)

Story continues below
Yes, the kids in tonight's premiere (8 p.m., Ch. 13) behave abominably. Four-year-old Dylan hits, swears, bosses, throws stuff and makes his parents' lives miserable. His 3-year-old sister, Natalie, isn't much better.

I suppose you could say there's even some public service done here as Nanny Deb teaches parents Matt and Karen what they're doing wrong — that "the issues lie more with the parents than with the kids."

She goes on to demonstrate that that is, indeed, the case.

But these are still real, live kids being called "every parent's worst nightmare" and being shown on national TV for our entertainment. (Although "entertainment" is a relative term.)

And there's something about that that makes "Nanny 911" even more reprehensible than going to "Temptation Island" or lying to your family about your "Big Fat Obnoxious Fiance."


E-mail: pierce@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Nanny Deb

previousnext

Latest comments

I would submit that anyone who has a problem with that stuff and wants it...

LOVED THE ARTICLE! as usual. Get a grip lady is almost as funny but not quite.

House gives Real honor

Now on to prepare the visit with Pres. Obama for March.

Big shots help Lone Peak edge Lehi

I held my kid back. He has asked me if I held him back because I thought he...

BYU fans still taking credit from what others teams do. Actually I don't see...

Big shots help Lone Peak edge Lehi

so should everyone that has kids that play sports hold their kids out?

Ever noticed how the "Anti-Capitolism" people go hand in hand with the MAN...

continued from previous post: The LDS church is very generous with this...

Letters: Explaining Palin

@Ernest T. Bass 4:57 p.m.: "If they ran the government on the principles...

House gives Real honor

Cool! Now let's hope this sparks a little more interest and support of the...

Advertisements