From Deseret News archives:

Ivory on again: Utah Supreme Court gives nod

Published: Friday, Oct. 29, 2004 4:24 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The legal roller coaster that has been the Salt Lake County mayoral race finally ended Thursday, with the Utah Supreme Court ruling that Ellis Ivory can go on the ballot as the official Republican candidate.

"I'm very pleased," Ivory said.

Ivory, who began his mayoral campaign as a write-in candidate three weeks ago, was the official GOP candidate for a short time beginning Wednesday morning, when County Clerk Sherrie Swensen certified him.

Third District Judge Stephen Henriod overruled Swensen that afternoon. The Supreme Court overruled Henriod less than 12 hours later.

In a one-page order, Associate Chief Justice Michael Wilkins wrote that a note from Nancy Workman's doctor, Philip Roberts, certifying her as disabled "substantially complies with the minimal requirements" of state law.

The court will release a detailed opinion later, perhaps today.

According to the law, Workman's "disabled" condition is a prerequisite to replacing her on the ballot. State and county Democratic Party leaders had argued that Roberts' note was legally insufficient - Henriod called it "ambiguous" - but the Supreme Court disagreed.

"We're glad that this was addressed by the courts," state Democratic Party Chairman Donald Dunn said. "Now we feel confident that the voters will make the final decision."

Story continues below
Independent candidate Merrill Cook, who has called Roberts' note "fraudulent" and "a sham," briefly considered a further legal challenge, based on whether Workman was really disabled, but ultimately decided against it. The court's order specifically expressed "no opinion as to whether or not Mayor Workman is, in fact, disabled," Wilkins wrote, and most of the legal argument before the court focused on the sufficiency of Roberts' note, not Workman's actual condition.

"I spoke with my attorney, and we have decided not to do anything . . . ," Cook said Thursday night. "It's a complicated thing at this stage because of the timing and because I don't want to be seen as interferring."

Democratic mayoral candidate Peter Corroon — who was against his party going to court from the beginning — said he is "happy to go toe to toe with the new candidate."

The legal process was a speedy one. The suit was filed Wednesday morning, Henriod made his ruling Wednesday afternoon, the Supreme Court heard arguments late Thursday morning and released its decision early that afternoon — an 18-hour sequence from start to finish.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

County mayoral candidates Ellis Ivory, left, Peter Corroon and Merrill Cook participate in a debate at Westminster College Thursday.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

I do read some of these comments about BYU and Utah...does seem like a lot of...

Eagle Mountain keeps Jackson

In the interest of full disclosure, the DN should have noted that Mayor Olsen...

Stereotypes are created and fed by just this type of behavior. All Utes are...

Obama's a Muslim? Did they tract him out or was he a referral?

BYU is champion of the state

3 out of 4 wins against Utah, and with all the crying on this message board I...

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

with the number of fans who see no problem with what Max Hall feels and says...

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

The level-headed, intelligent, emotionally stable Y fans are embarrassed to...

To those who suggest the U condones classless behavior by fans, note that the...

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

freshman Jordan Wynn showed more class than Max Hall, on and off the field....

Hall mouths off about hate of Utah

Fair question right? I mean if you are going to throw everyone in are you...

Advertisements