From Deseret News archives:

Welfare reform failing?

Utah advocates for poor question Cato grading system

Published: Monday, Oct. 18, 2004 10:32 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Utah's efforts at welfare reform are failing, a leading public policy think tank announced Monday.

The Cato Institute's report card of state welfare programs gave Utah an F along with seven other states and the District of Columbia.

Analysts at the institute, which is nonprofit, libertarian and seeks to limit the role of government, doled out just four A's, seven B's, 20 C's, and 11 D's.

The report looked at policy reforms by states the past seven years since the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA) was signed into law.

Specifically, it slammed Utah for failing to implement a "family cap" to discourage additional births while on welfare, for ranking 47th in the decline of the birthrate for minors and for allowing continued subsidization of teenage parenthood.

The state earned the low marks even as Cato's policy analysts observed a state budget surplus, lower unemployment rates than much of the nation and high job growth — all factors that could reduce welfare rolls.

"There is no reason Utah cannot succeed in reducing dependence" on welfare, the report noted.

Story continues below
Administrators of Utah's leading advocacy group for the poor said the public should keep in mind that "welfare" reform depends largely on the tools of measurement.

"You have to look at where they are coming from," said Utah Issues' Pam Silberman. "For them, the greatest result of welfare reform would be the elimination of the welfare system. . . . The way they grade the states, be it succeeding or failing, has to viewed with that lens."

The grading system looked at, among other things, overall caseload reduction and moving people into the work force.

While that appears noble at first blush, Silberman noted that Utah's system failed to get any credit for its emphasis on job training or educational training to get people into higher-paying jobs.

"That is a positive feature of Utah's welfare program, that job training and job education count toward the work requirement. . . . You can't reduce poverty if you just send people out to the first minimum wage job they find."

Officials from the state Department of Workforce Services, the agency that administers welfare money, agree.

"We think that education and training is key to reduced poverty in the long run," said Mike Richardson, head of the agency's delivery support services.

"And that is what we hear from employers — they tell us they need an educated work force."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Deseret Morning News graphic

previousnext

Latest comments

Tiger needs to convert to the FLDS faith so he can marry all of these women...

Letters: Roundabouts great

I agree with whoever said it works well when there's only one lane of traffic...

Cougars in better mood about bowl

"Your not a BYU Grad." By the way, it is YOU ARE not a BYU Grad, not your....

Cougars in better mood about bowl

Undergraduate and graduate, my friend, which is why I am disappointed in:...

lets not put all the blame on Anserson. His marketing team had a big part in...

Some of our children and grandchildren were friends with Jared and they...

Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax

Mr. Anderson was not alone in this hoax... I understand that Bryan has fessed...

That is so dumb! I think I will listen to 98% of all scientists and NOT the...

I think it is sad and pathetic that any team would play worse and be less...

Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax

What were the Flash thinking? Do they not teach business ethics at BYU? I...

Advertisements