From Deseret News archives:

Keep court records open

Published: Wednesday, Sept. 15, 2004 9:34 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
In the future, when this newspaper, or any other, wants to get a database of convicted drunken drivers — to see how their cases were handled, whether they were sentenced properly or to discover any other important trends — a reporter may have to beg in front of a government committee to get permission.

That's the recommendation of the Committee on Privacy and Public Court Records, which has issued its draft recommendations on how open the courts ought to be. This will be forwarded to the Utah Judicial Council for consideration. It could cloud the way you view the court system in the future.

It also might be unconstitutional.

A majority on the committee believes there is a big difference between a paper report and an electronic one — so much of a difference that they are in a frenzy to seal up information that has been public for decades. They don't mind keeping the paper records open, but they want to keep the public's hands off the entire database, which is where the stories of larger public interest reside.

It's safe to say many members of this committee — with the exception of those representing the interests of news organizations — are not friends of public accountability. Incredibly, some of them were even adamant that the draft itself should be kept private so as to not generate a lot of messy public debate about how the public's records are maintained.

Story continues below
Others wanted the draft to include contempt-of-court contempt of court penalties against anyone who disseminated the information in a legally obtained private document, which would have precipitated a train wreck with the First Amendment.

These were astounding recommendations coming from people with legal training. Fortunately, cooler heads prevailed on both ideas. In the end, we hope they prevail on the larger issue, as well.

We agree that the differences between paper and electronic records can be enormous. With an electronic database, a news organization (or any other group, for that matter) can keep courts, police departments and all other government agencies accountable. This newspaper, for example, has a keen interest in promoting DUI legislation and programs that work. Unless we have the ability to examine public records as a whole, it would be impossible to identify what those are.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Make Region 9 and St. George proud! Good luck to the Tigers of Hurricane too!

I do beieve JIMS time is up here in So.Utah..!! Out with the old and in with...

There might be a few more woman here in Utah. More so than the national...

This election cycle is starting to look like the perfect storm to clean...

Yeah, that's a good idea. Lets move the rivalry game to a stadium that less...

Doomsday sect's future in doubt

As the French say, "The more things change, the more they stay the same."...

U. hopes to keep clicking

If the Utes pull out a win against TCU, it will only be because TCU made...

Sandy may give $10K to bowl game

Sandy residents must love their football more than the average football fan,...

We will all pay to some extent, but what you probably wanted to ask was how...

Fedor has been busy his wife recently had a baby and he posted here the other...

Advertisements
Advertisement