From Deseret News archives:

Old laws may play role in gun duel

State and U. could rely on similar territorial strategy

Published: Friday, Aug. 27, 2004 10:57 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The shootout between the University of Utah and Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff over banning guns on campus may dip back to the days when Utah was still a territory.

When attorneys representing the attorney general and the U. meet for oral arguments Monday before the Utah Supreme Court, it is expected that the state will rely, in part, upon territorial law to show that the university must comply with state law and not be allowed limited legal autonomy.

"We believe the gun issue is ultimately an academic issue," said Alan Sullivan, attorney for the University of Utah.

It has been a legal, and political, tug of war that has lasted more than two years. University officials say allowing people to carry guns on campus would stifle the academic atmosphere at the state-run institution. Officials point to provisions in the state constitution that grant the university limited autonomy from state law to maintain academic freedom. The university has had a policy banning guns on campus for 30 years.

In August of last year, 3rd District Judge Robert Hilder ruled in favor of the university's policy. The Utah Legislature fired back during its last session, passing SB48, which specified that the Legislature, not school officials, can set gun policies. Gov. Olene Walker signed the bill into law last March.

Story continues below
Deputy Attorney General Brent Burnett said the issue over whether Utah's statutes applied to the U. is now moot due to the passage of SB48. "The only issue in front of the court is the question whether for some things, the University of Utah has grounds under the state constitution" to make policy contrary to state law in the event officials believe it's bad public policy.

Burnett said the state may use an 1892 territorial law to argue before the Supreme Court. The law, which was enacted before Utah became a state, made it clear that the U. had to comply with the law of the territory as a "public corporation."

Sullivan says he sees the territorial laws as supporting the university's position. Pointing to territorial laws enacted in 1850, 1851 and 1892, Sullivan said territorial laws established the state Board of Regents and trustees of the U. and gave them authority over all academic issues on campus. Because the university sees guns on campus as an academic issue, they feel they have the better argument.

Under Utah law, guns can only be banned in courtrooms, jails, prisons, airports and mental health institutions.

If the Supreme Court rules in favor of the state, Sullivan said the issue is still pending in federal court and that the university may pursue that avenue.

Burnett said instead of fighting the state in court, university officials should take their case to the Legislature. "The Legislature is the body that has the power and the duty to make the laws in the state of Utah. If the university believes the law needs to be changed, the AG has said all along that they have a right to go to the Legislature," Burnett said.


E-mail: gfattah@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I am not super familiar with Buddhist beliefs, but don't these books have...

Max Hall issues apology

Most of these comments are indicators of the sad state of our society! There...

RSL's Movsisyan departs

I can't agree with you more. The only thing holding soccer back in this...

Corroon a step closer to governor

Right now I am leaning towards Herbert, but I must admit I like Corroon too....

I'm tired of the twin religions - atheism and secularism being supported by...

Wow -- this is amazingly ironic. After years of accusing BYU and is fans of...

Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal

Clearly Amy has never strapped on a helmet and tried to knock the living tar...

NBA notes: Nets coach fired

Count on the Nets being 0-25 when they play at the Jazz on Dec. 16th. The...

Jazz notes: Injuries mounting

Lawrence Frank is overall a good coach. I wonder if Jazz can recruit him in...

Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal

of Hall's family is the real story. Why aren't U fans and the University...

Advertisements