From Deseret News archives:

Some feel S.L. club is pushing racy book

Published: Wednesday, Aug. 25, 2004 9:40 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Just three weeks before it officially kicks off, the first-ever city-sponsored book club is generating controversy with one of its first recommendations.

And the Salt Lake City mayor's office hunkered down Monday to head off an anticipated firestorm over the book club's profanity- and blasphemy-laced choice.

Meanwhile, at least one councilman has asked the mayor's office to consider picking a new book and plans to question Rocky Anderson's staffers about the selection at tonight's City Council meeting.

City officials apparently became aware of the controversy Monday after the Deseret Morning News inquired about the book "The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time," by English author Mark Haddon.

The popular book about an autistic Sherlock Holmes wannabe who uncovers the truth about a slain dog is replete with four-letter words, including at least 22 f-words, 16 s-words and 33 profane references to Jesus Christ and God.

Oftentimes profanity and blasphemy are strung for greater effect, as in the line: "Holy f---ing J----, Christopher. How stupid are you?"

In addition to other curse words, the book includes a four-letter reference to female anatomy that — in context — is "horribly abusive" to women, one council member said.

Story continues below
"If young men were talking to their girlfriends and mothers that way, we as a society would be offended and rightfully so," Councilman Eric Jergensen said. "We as a society should not be recommending this type of literature."

Annette Daley, the only person on the mayor's book committee who is a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, agreed there weren't many, if any, social conservatives on the panel who might have provided more balance to the selection process.

"This is the mayor's book club, and the mayor certainly doesn't make any beans about the fact that he's not conservative," she said. "(The committee members) reflect his political and intellectual ideologies."

Daley said she loved the book and believes others of her faith can enjoy it. After all, she said, kids hear worse language in high school.

After fielding questions from the Deseret Morning News, the mayor's public relations machine whipped into gear Monday as spokeswoman Deeda Seed called the Salt Lake Tribune to alert the paper about censorship concerns.

Next, Seed pow-wowed with Anderson's chief-of-staff Sam Guevara (the mayor is on vacation in Cambodia), who told her to write Op-Ed pieces for both the Morning News and the Tribune in an effort to head off a possible brewing controversy.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Williams returns to team

I Think Deron is the best point guard in the league and Eric Maynor is going...

nice analogy thank you

Letters: Don't penalize teachers

What's a babysitter make these days, $3/hr.? Times 6 hours per day = $18....

To bad the weather was so bad, didn't really get to see either offense...

BYU is fading, fading fast... UTES will stomp on the Cougers again and...

Well, if you are only going to keep Vegas and San Diego because of location...

The church used to discourage such tourism temple tours that were operated by...

Wounded Utes limp home

Ah, you clueless Ute fans. Refuting your comments is so easy it's almost...

The game cant end in a tie.. Ties are not about everyone going home happy.....

Wounded Utes limp home

I actually agree with you for the most part. These teams are pretty close to...

Advertisements
Advertisement