From Deseret News archives:

Choice does improve schooling

Published: Saturday, July 24, 2004 7:08 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Parents are seizing new opportunities to choose their children's schools through vouchers and charter schools. But does such school choice improve learning and lead to other improvements in schooling? The evidence from a variety of studies shows that it does.

Analyses of student achievement indicate that school choice leads to higher levels of learning in various parts of the United States and other countries. Better studies show stronger and more consistent effects, and no study points to substantially poorer performance of choice schools.

Surveys show that parents most often choose private and public charter schools with academic standards superior to regular public schools. Parents are as adept as education experts in evaluating the academic offerings. To meet parents' desires for such offerings, charter schools are expanding their numbers and enrollments.

Required new achievement reporting in all 50 states helps parents pinpoint failing schools and choose the best school for their children. Unlike regular schools, moreover, schools of choice that fail to attract parents must close, which leaves the successful schools of choice to prosper and further enlarge opportunities.

Story continues below
In geographic areas with larger numbers of schools of choice, regular public schools achieve more, have higher graduation rates, and cost less than regular schools in other similar areas with little choice. The positive effects of competition are also notable in metropolitan and urban areas containing multiple school districts that consistently outperform areas with a single monopolistic school district such as Los Angeles and New York City. The poor performance of public schools, particularly in such large districts, is attributable to unwieldy and wasteful central bureaucracies that are inherently less sensitive to parent concerns and preferences.

School choice is also effective among special-needs students with physical and mental problems such as those in Florida's McKay Scholarship program. More than 90 percent of parents of McKay children were satisfied with their chosen schools, far more than other parents of other special-needs students in non-chosen schools.

Depending on their own preferences, McKay parents can choose between schools that focus on a particular disability or schools that integrate children with and without disabilities. Parent surveys also show that McKay students suffer far less harassment and physical attacks than their peers attending non-chosen public schools.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Having made enough dumb mistakes myself I can now let this go. Max had...

If People kept track of what they eat and report it to their Doctors then we...

Letters: Therapy for Hall

I'm glad that he said something. Fans need to know what kind of danger they...

It is football folks - rivalry football - go to a ACC, SEC, PAC 10, Big 10,...

Religion in politics is tiresome

The religious people wouldn't be up in arms if religion wasn't already under...

U. eyes bowl for redemption

There is only one source of redemption and it is not the Bowl Committee. The...

Ohhhh BOO HOO....you poor picked on Yewt fans! Maybe you should pack it...

Utes won't respond to Hall

Aaahhh the agony we put ourselves through, Hall's comments were thoughtless...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

between Max Hall's words AFTER a heated game and M. Scalley or P. Krueger's...

Max Hall does not have to sink to the level of the Utes fans that abused his...

Advertisements