From Deseret News archives:

Don't put tax dollars into soccer stadium

Published: Saturday, July 17, 2004 11:09 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Next time you're down there, look closely at the neighborhood around Franklin Covey Field in Salt Lake City. Would you consider it economically vibrant?

How about this: Would you consider the stadium, located at 1300 South and West Temple, to be the southern anchor to downtown, or even close to downtown?

We in the media often forget to follow up on the statements politicians make in order to justify public expenditures. In 1993, Mayor Deedee Corradini was disappointed that, for political reasons, she couldn't build the baseball stadium in the heart of downtown, where she hoped it would help energize investment. But she believed the site where it ended up would do wonders for that area, instead, bringing a real return on the investment of public funds.

In part, she was relying on a study by the consulting firm KPMG Peat Marwick, which estimated the stadium would generate about $7 million annually in the community. She said companies, which she declined to name, had shown interest in moving in near the stadium.

In a news story I wrote on May 4, 1993, I quoted her as saying, "I envision 10 years from now the stadium will define the south end of downtown."

Eleven years have passed. You decide.

Story continues below
The neighborhood certainly hasn't declined, but it hasn't been developed much, either. Minor league baseball isn't exactly the hottest ticket in town.

I'm not trying to bash the former mayor or her consultants. I bring this up only because a bit of history may have relevance if the people of Utah get asked to help build a new soccer stadium.

And they will get asked. My sources tell me the question already is being asked.

Utah scored a major coup last week when Major League Soccer awarded a franchise to a Salt Lake City investor group led by Dave Checketts. The MLS may not be on a par with the NFL or major league baseball, but soccer remains the world's most popular sport, and this will help position the city internationally as the sport grows and blossoms in the United States.

But pro soccer, even at this high level, still is a gamble. Two years ago, MLS killed teams in Miami and Tampa Bay because of a lack of attendance. According to the Bloomberg news service, the Los Angeles Galaxy last year became the first team in the league's history to turn a profit, and that was only $150,000. There are no guarantees people here will flock to the games.

But even if they did, governments have no business spending public funds to build a stadium, even if it's only for part of the costs.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall

Give it a rest?? A stripling warrior and a standard bearer of the values...

Lakers crush Jazz in 4th quarter

I put the 2nd half on my DVR, but forget watching the ending now after I saw...

From 6 min left in the 3rd Qtr, the Jazz were outscored 42 - 11. How is that...

Palin signs books, chats with fans

I was stupid enough to attend the U. Of U., receive good grades, and earn two...

dumb!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I hate the lakers 6 points bother me more than the loss

Casual sex not always bad for health?

It's what these polled people believe that matters. If they believe there is...

I loved the first 3 quarters, but when the Lakers clamped down, the Jazz...

TINA FEY WAS IN SALT LAKE?! Doesn't she have 30 rock to film? hmmmm...

Lakers crush Jazz in 4th quarter

that was the jazz in the 3rd & 4th qrtr? no way. the jazz left staples center...

Advertisements