From Deseret News archives:

To Iraqis, prisoner abuse story is largely a non-issue

Published: Saturday, May 8, 2004 5:54 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
It is Friday, May 7, 2004, the Muslim "weekend."

And the news here is apparently much different than there. From my early morning looks at the news channels, it looks like the "prisoner story" is dominating the national news. It appears to us to be taking on all the signs of an overreaction to a very negative and unfortunate incident.

It's amazing to us that people are calling for Rumsfeld's resignation or firing. Interestingly, it's mostly a non-event for most of the Iraqis with whom we work or meet. A typical reaction came from one of our key staff I'll call Abdul. He has a degree in English literature, is in his mid-30s, served in the Iraqi Army during the Iraq-Iran War, has a side business in women's cosmetics, and works with us in the coordination of several of our social institutions. He is somewhat typical of the many more educated Iraqis.

Story continues below
When I questioned him about how most Iraqis view the prisoner abuse story, his first reaction was a startled stare. He didn't really even connect with my question. When I explained more fully, he said, "Well, actually, sir, to be quite honest with you, we think that it represents a small dot on a large piece of paper. We know that the hearts of almost all Americans are good and they do so much good for our people. And remember, sir, we lived under Saddam for nearly 30 years. To be quite honest with you, sir, we believe that the media is not fair and has not been fair for this entire war. After all, we Iraqis watch every despicable act committed by terrorists as they are glorified by Al Jazeera."

Nearly all our translators and Iraqi staff indicate basically the same thing. Many Iraqis, even those who have televisions and watch Al Jazeera, are mostly nonplussed by the prisoner story.

I do not mean to excuse or justify these acts in any way. It is an obvious black eye and tarnishes all that we're attempting to do here. The overwhelming consensus among the military working here in the Palace is abhorrence and an attitude that the enlisted personnel and their commanders ought to be dealt with appropriately and severely after a full investigation. Most are concerned that this is further tarnishing unfairly the military image back in the states, painting broad strokes across the entire canvas. I can tell you from my own experience that, for the most part, this is the best trained and dedicated group of people who could ever possibly serve the United States.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I didn't know they needed protection. I wouldn't have a problem hiring a gay...

" Ask anyone who uses these things and they will tell you they want to keep...

5A football: Bingham over Syracuse

I'm a Bingham fan to the core but have to think that if your boy plays the...

The Coaches play a big part in building a team, but the make spark comes from...

Wyoming writer amazed by BYU

You may want to take a line from Mendenhall and have more class, oh but he...

Paa - I can answer your question. As for proof, just as with any...

To FOR Fort Hood victims. Could you please put your remarks in context of...

Wasatch defense stifles Desert Hills

Forum, to call out people, or to mock and make fun of in St George because...

Were the soldiers at Ft. Hood constitutional rights violated by Major Nidal?

U. hopes to keep clicking

I don't disagree with much of what you say, but here's a question for you. ...

Advertisements
Advertisement