From Deseret News archives:

Readers not afraid to speak their minds

Published: Sunday, May 9, 2004 12:27 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Pignanelli: LaVarr and I have been writing this column together for almost six months. While bestowing our subjective view of Utah politics, we have mocked important politicians and challenged respected institutions. Each column has generated some mild responses. But the volume, content and emotional reaction to the recent edition regarding illegal immigration was astonishing.

Almost half of the numerous e-mails were from outside Utah. An overwhelming majority (90 percent) disagreed with our position of allowing illegal immigrants temporary work permits for agricultural operations. They ranged across the spectrum of civilized decorum. The most courteous objection originated from a reader in California: "So much of your article is outside the realm of rational debate." The worst was a suggestion that LaVarr and I undertake an activity that is anatomically impossible for human beings.

In order to share these snippets of American prose, I have categorized them for our readers' convenience. (Remember, these are actual e-mails.)

Story continues below
Those from another planet provided insightful statements such as: "My teen was looking for a job but was barred from a neighborhood job because adult illegal aliens are working the job American citizen teens seek." Also, "Americans can and will do these jobs you claim they refuse to do & Americans consider jobs such as flipping burgers to be the providence of teenagers and college students . . . Last summer some 600,000 college students could not find jobs, because these illegal aliens you love so much had taken them." (Notice to McDonald's: Expect long lines of college students seeking minimum-wage jobs.)

The completely clueless offered: "Instead of relying on manual labor, maybe the farmers and growers should obtain or invent technology that allows them to harvest their food without employing so many people." (No suggestions proffered how the agricultural industry collects food in the meantime.) "So, you're a descendant of immigrants and they 'worked hard.' So what! It wasn't the racial diversity that built this country . . . but often it was actually often racism that contributed to the building of this country (i.e., slavery) unfortunately." (How is that for sensitivity?)

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Discrimination is something we all do (and should do) every day. When we go...

Both parties disrespect Constitution

is genius. And the many of the poster hereon, provides the explanation. A...

To Anonymous @7:15 a.m., If you want to be free to rent your property only to...

And how is the Constitution to grow? I think the framers thought it would be...

Audit calls for end to 'double dipping'

If demand is there then what's the problem? If the state offers early...

Who cares, just want to see the big boys play, not the little leagues. You...

3A football: Wasatch vs. Juan Diego

JD is "that good" or they wouldn't be in the game. I assume Wasatch is also...

sounds like a great recruit, Now let's see what BYU will do with him, I'll...

Read the article. What does BYU's year of mediocrity have to do with...

This is ridiculous. Why are we rehiring people into their same positions...

Advertisements
Advertisement