From Deseret News archives:

Shortage of nurses can be deadly

Hospitals are pressured to set limits on patient loads

Published: Saturday, March 27, 2004 9:40 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Becky Hartman will tell you how crucial it is for a hospital to have enough nurses.

When she rushed her mother to a Wichita, Kan., hospital, an ER doctor quickly sized up the older woman as another pneumonia case. Her breathing was labored, and pneumonia patients filled the emergency room.

But 61-year-old Shirley Keck didn't have pneumonia. As she lay in a hospital room all but ignored, she was suffering from a common type of heart failure that filled her lungs with fluid.

As Keck deteriorated over several hours, Hartman begged Wesley Hospital nurses for help.

"It was total chaos. Everybody was tired. Everybody was totally overworked," Hartman recalls. "As the breathing got worse, I'd ring the button. Nobody came."

It was Feb. 8, 1998 — a Sunday night, when hospital staffs are leanest. There were just two registered nurses and two nurse aides for 42 patients on Keck's floor, fewer than half the staff the hospital's own guidelines required.

"I'm going to die," Shirley Keck told her daughter.

She did, but was resuscitated and lingered for four years — depressed, paralyzed except for one arm and unable to talk because a stroke during the ordeal had caused brain damage.

Story continues below
Her family sued and won a $2.7 million malpractice settlement from Wesley Hospital in July 2000. Two years later, Keck died.

The hospital and Keck's attorney, Bradley Prochaska, say it's the first malpractice decision specifically pinned on inadequate nurse staffing. He has filed a similar suit involving a 38-year-old quadriplegic woman.

At first, Hartman was furious with the nurses. Now, she's joined their cause, speaking out about the need for more nurses at the bedside.

"If another family doesn't go through this, the nightmares I've had," she says, "that's all I can ask for."

Across the country, nurses unions are pushing hospitals and lawmakers for limits on patient loads. And hospitals are trying to recruit and keep more nurses, all with good reason: Too few nurses can cost patients their health and sometimes their lives, study after study shows.

• A shortage of nurses is a factor in about one-fourth of patient injuries or deaths in hospitals, according to the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations' 2002 report.

• The prestigious Institute of Medicine says long work hours and fatigue contribute to errors. Its November 2003 report recommends a ban on nurses working longer than 12 hours a day.

Recent comments

I guess a 2.7 million lawsuit was not enough to motivate wesley into...

Anonymous | Feb. 14, 2008 at 10:21 p.m.

Image
Larry W. Smith, Associated Press

Becky Hartman and her family won a $2.7 million malpractice settlement over the lack of care for her mother.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Homosexual activity may be a sin, and gay marriage a deviation, but to...

Aetna insurance 600,000 health insurance clients dropped. Unicare...

re:"Good to see... | 12:36 p.m. Dec. 8, 2009 one of the instate coaches has...

Letters: N-waste good for economy

If it's so safe why don't the Italians bury their nuclear waste in Italy?...

ok BSU owns the whole state of Utah and TCU you too!!

Revive full food tax?

Pretty special folks out there in IL. Do you pronounce the "S" at the end of...

@Invention of the internet 4:03 p.m.: "Al Gore never took credit for...

...With the earlier post that said Boise State has a light schedule. Compared...

Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax

I'm an engineering student and Anderson came and spoke at a seminar in my...

Thank you Desert News for reminding us of the good in this world. And thank...

Advertisements