Top court urged to drop BLM Utah case
U.S. Solicitor General Theodore B. Olson filed a brief arguing that the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals erred when it sided with environmental groups in ruling that the Interior Department was not doing as much as required by law to protect wilderness-like areas in Utah from damage by off-road vehicles.
They brought their suit under a section of the Administrative Procedure Act that allows suing "to compel any agency action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed." Olson argues the 10th Circuit improperly expanded that to allow review of the adequacy of an agency's ongoing management not just whether it is acting at all.
Olson argues that a proper interpretation of the law should be that "although a court may direct an agency to act when action is clearly required by law, a court may not direct an agency how to act."
He said if the lower court decision stands, it "would invite the district court improperly to substitute its judgment and discretion for those of the agency." He argued, "Such judicial intrusion into the responsibility of the executive branch is inconsistent with the separation of powers under the Constitution."
Olson also said a 1990 Supreme Court ruling in Lujan v. National Wildlife Federation about another section of the same law also cautioned that environmental groups "cannot seek wholesale improvement of (an agency's) program by court decree, rather than in the offices of the Department or the halls of Congress, where programmatic improvements are normally made."
The new case, (Interior Secretary Gale) Norton v. Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance, is scheduled for oral argument before the Supreme Court on March 29, and the sides are in the process of filing written briefs. A response from environmental groups to the government's arguments is due later this month.
In the lower court decision, the Bureau of Land Management was ordered to manage Utah lands, which are being considered for formal wilderness designation, so that off-road vehicle use would not impair their wilderness values; to manage ORVs in accordance with land use plans; and to look at whether more environmental review of activities was needed because of ORV damage.
Olson argued the case essentially tries improperly to give goals and land-use plans of the Interior Department the same force as if they were statutory law.
He said that instead, "a land use plan is a fluid, process-oriented document" and how well its goals are met are "contingent on available resources and competing priorities." He said courts should not impose their agenda and priorities instead of those of the administration.
Comments
- Luxury home market stalls 12:02 p.m.
- Kirk Douglas classic on DVD 11:38 a.m.
- Zion fire moving southeast 11:36 a.m.
- More school-money than expected 11:24 a.m.
- Virginia 'Freedman's' project done 11:12 a.m.
- Teen relive Mormon trek 11:12 a.m.
- Oldest American to scale Mount Everest 11:07 a.m.
- Knicks sign first-round pick 10:59 a.m.
- Armstrong third, Leipheimer fourthe 10:58 a.m.
- 6.0 quake in China 10:43 a.m.
- Jazz brass debate Millsap match
- LDS seminary principal arrested
- 2 men cited on LDS plaza
- Jazz finances not quite so bleak
- HBO defends U. logo use in 'Love'
- Reactions on Boozer speculation
- Cash for Clunkers to get rolling soon
- Utahns among Texans' investors
- Man spots his stolen car
- Jazz rookies quiet Thunder youngsters
- LDS seminary principal arrested
261 - Jazz brass debate Millsap match
168 - Bronco collecting a galaxy of recruits
141 - Jazz talking Boozer trade?
140 - 2 men cited on LDS plaza
127 - Blazers may offer Millsap a contract
124 - Stadium of Fire flag burning was fake
99 - Fairness of BCS debated
81 - Chaffetz eyes challenging Bennett
76 - Letters: Single-payer system best
75
As more and more dads are put out of work in this economy, I've been...
The photographs are mysterious, brooding, dark. They show dimples and...
Guess what?!! The rest of the world thinks MORMONS ARE NOT MORAL!!!
@If I were Obama | 7:25 a.m. So funny. LMAO with this comment. Just...
"Fight the Power" is trying to make a civil rights analogy here that...
To imply that seniority is any substitute for effort under Jerry Sloan is...
Both for us fans and Jazz management. Millie was a great 2nd round pick,...
Like so many laws suits, Utah will loose. This use isn't any violation of...
"The Sutherland institute study shows that 96% of the immigrants lead crime...
continued: But most important, her gaffes reveal one who is woefully lacking...
suffers from a terrible case of 'god complex' wherein he thinks he is god the...
Biden or Sarah Palin? Looking at a catalogue of Biden’s gaffes, one is...


You can be the first to comment on this story.