From Deseret News archives:

New nominee ploy by Hatch

Published: Friday, Sept. 26, 2003 7:30 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, evoked a chorus of protest from Democrats and liberal groups Thursday when he opened a new front in the ongoing war over conservative judicial nominees.

Without a new hearing or consultation with Democrats, Hatch brought up for committee vote the once-rejected nomination of U.S. District Judge Charles Pickering of Mississippi to be elevated to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals. Democrats complained loudly, and used committee rules to delay that vote at least a week.

Last year when Democrats controlled the committee, it rejected Pickering's nomination on a 10-9 party-line vote amid charges that he is racist and too pro-life on abortion to follow the law. Hatch complained bitterly that the accusations are false, and said Pickering had enough votes in the full Senate to win confirmation.

When Republicans regained control of the Senate this year, President Bush renominated Pickering. Hatch vowed to have new hearings on him, and to put him in line for action — more or less — behind other nominations in order that they were received.

But when Hatch put Pickering on the agenda for a vote without a new hearing and ahead of other nominees, Democrats howled.

Story continues below
Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., the committee's ranking Democrat, complained that the committee until this year had never reconsidered a rejected nominee, and even accused Hatch of racial insensitivity with his timing in attempting it now.

"Given the many concerns about Judge Pickering voiced by African-Americans in Mississippi and all over the country … it was most ill-advised to abruptly list the nomination at the time that the Congressional Black Caucus is involved in its Annual Legislative Conference," Leahy said.

He added that if Hatch and Republicans felt the record about Pickering is wrong, they should have held a new hearing to correct it. He noted that four of the 19 members on the committee have joined it since Pickering's last hearing.

Hatch made no response during the hearing, but has said he feels the record has shown Pickering deserves confirmation. For example, while some liberal groups attack him on civil rights, Hatch noted that Pickering, as a young attorney, testified against the Ku Klux Klan when it was dangerous to do so.

On Thursday, Hatch distributed a letter supporting Pickering from the top five statewide Democratic office holders in Pickering's native Mississippi, including Gov. Ronnie Musgrove, Attorney General Mike Moore and Secretary of State Eric Clark.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Isn't the logical conclusion of Russell's rant that man can do whatever he...

Here's what Glenn Beck knows about the constitution but won't say on the air:...

Yes, there is no global warming. Those of you that didn't know that, stand on...

Non-BCS schools not given fair shot

I am with you. Bronco is a much better coach than Kyle. He deserves a BCS...

Boy those scientists sure are brilliant. Good thing they told us the climate...

Letters: No man-made warming

"orchestrated suppression of any evidence and researchers that doesn't...

instead of being negative against people on the team be glad they won. the...

Hot Rod behind mic for Lakers

Any chance the Lakers will take David Locke instead? Locke is a good talk...

Civilians getting killed in a war. Gosh, it happens. Nothing you can do...

We have a Spanish branch within our English ward here in Washington state. I...

Advertisements