AP: Utah Utes — Irony illustrates need for playoff

Published: Tuesday, Jan. 13, 2009 2:26 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Could the Urban Irony of another BCS-mired college football season be a precursor to the Barack Playoff System?

With President-elect Obama still beating the drum for an eight-team national championship playoff even after Thursday's Bowl Championship Series title game ...

With Utah's Attorney General Mark Shurtleff investigating a possible anti-trust lawsuit against the BCS ...

And with Texas congressman Joe Barton proposing legislation to replace the BCS with a playoff system... who knows?

Maybe, with Barton being a Republican, the cause celeb will help bridge the great partisan divide in Washington, D.C.

If nothing else, Urban Irony sure would make a fitting title for the last chapter of the 2008-09 edition of BCS Giveth, and BCS Taketh Away.

Who would know better than Florida coach Urban Meyer?

His Gators have capitalized on Bowl Championship Series' flaws at least once (Boise State would probably say twice), and his former Utah Utes have been victimized by them twice.

Ironically, Meyer lobbied for a playoff in the past. By his own admission, he was a "big proponent" in 2004, when his 11-0 Utes failed to get a shot at the national championship. But this time around, he's avoiding the controversy.

Story continues below
And nobody's going to get him to suggest Utah, the only undefeated team in the country, should have shared the championship with Florida.

Now that Meyer and his Gators are once again the proud beneficiaries of a national title, thanks to the BCS and a 24-14 victory over Oklahoma, he's not about to bite the hand that feeds his Gators.

That's quite a change in tune from 2004, when he declared Utah deserving of a shot at the title, saying that team could have beaten anybody on a given day. Too bad Meyer couldn't be a little humble and admit the 2008 edition of the Utes was even more deserving. Kyle Whittingham's No. 2-ranked Utes beat a pair of Top 10 teams — No. 6 Alabama and No. 7 TCU — plus No. 18 Oregon State and No. 25 Brigham Young.

Whittingham has a far more legitimate beef with the BCS than Meyer did in 2004, when the Utes finished the season at 12-0, and ranked fourth in the AP poll and fifth in the USA Today/ESPN coaches poll. There were also two 13-0 teams that season, No. 1 USC and No. 2 Auburn.

Whittingham was perfectly justified to vote his team No. 1 in the coaches poll, as were the 16 sportswriters who cast their first-place votes for Utah in the final AP poll. Too bad another 20 or so didn't follow suit, so the Utes could have shared the championship they justly deserved.

Shame on the coaches for ranking Utah fourth, behind No. 2 USC and No. 3 Texas.

Recent comments

Everyone, please stop using the term, Mid Major. It is offensive,...

Stop It! | Jan. 14, 2009 at 10:00 p.m.

My question is where is the NCAA? Is the NCAA an organization or is...

Where is the NCAA? | Jan. 14, 2009 at 12:43 p.m.

How come everyone brings up Georgia blowing out Hawaii as a negative...

Off the subject | Jan. 14, 2009 at 9:22 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Plea deals, now just what the heck are these. ADMIT GUILTY, then try to cry...

But the jobs and the positive economic impact on our state would be...

I am a big BYU fan, but this article is discouraging. Arizona handily beat...

USU shooters struggling so far

I agree with "shooting" that the percentage will go up over the next few...

Wow, just when I thought both sides could not be more girlish than I thought...

To "Getting it there | 8:20 a.m." the federal mandates for transporting...

BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall

Thanks for proving Max's point. You remind me of the elementary school...

Russell stares down fake Jordan

Sold out crowd -- and 3500 people who will never come back. Elin Woods wants...

Revive full food tax?

Last time I was in the check-out line, the poor in front of me were paying...

BYU professor remembered

Brother Lebaron was my favorite religious teacher. He made learning fun and...

Advertisements