From Deseret News archives:

Religion rose to divide us

Published: Saturday, Nov. 1, 2008 12:21 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
In 1961, after John F. Kennedy's Catholic faith proved not to be an insurmountable barrier to the White House, Billy Graham predicted that religion would never again be such a divisive force in elections.

The evangelist could not have anticipated YouTube, 24-hour news cycles and a roster of candidates featuring a Mormon, an African-American Protestant and someone raised in a Pentecostal church.

The intersection of religion and politics has endured its share of head-on collisions during the 2008 campaign — most involving candidates' religious resumes or those of people in their circles.

With a few exceptions, whatever seemed odd or fringe trumped serious discussion about how candidates' religious beliefs shape their approach to governance.

As the race nears its end, scholars and religious leaders are using terms like "new low" and "embarrassing" to describe how religious beliefs were distorted and picked over, while candidates were asked to mount theological defenses for their respective faiths or be held accountable for the views of others.

"Religion is reduced to the exotic or to morality bumper stickers, or just a trump card for identity politics," said Eric Gregory, an assistant professor of religion at Princeton University. "The focus becomes buzzwords or personal piety rather than the way religion impacts issues."

Story continues below
While campaign attacks involving religion go way back — Thomas Jefferson was accused of atheism and William Howard Taft came under fire for being a Unitarian — not since Kennedy's Catholicism was dissected has religion been so used as a weapon in an election.

Democrat Barack Obama has talked of bridging religious divides, and his campaign sought to reach out to religious voters on a scale unprecedented for a Democrat. Yet Obama's ability to speak more openly about religion in the public square was compromised by echoes of former pastor Jeremiah Wright thundering "God Damn America" in clips that dominated cable television for weeks last spring.

Obama finally cut ties with Wright, and the pastor's rhetoric receded from view — until this week, when it reappeared in TV ads produced by an independent Republican group.

Wright is fair game, critics of Obama and some neutral observers say, because the pastor and politician were clearly close and Obama did not leave the church until Wright forced his hand.

Recent comments

Wow, Obama is trash? Amazing that such a man of trash has...

jer | Nov. 1, 2008 at 10:25 p.m.

How utterly ridiculous to accuse LDS of rejecting Obama due to his...

Whoa, hold the phone | Nov. 1, 2008 at 8:15 p.m.

Hate to break it to you, but many no longer believe in being...

It's the 21st century people | Nov. 1, 2008 at 7:53 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

This was the first time I have had the chance to see the COugars play this...

Lets go WebCats!!! Congrats to Coach McBride and the entire squad for making...

Hey, Melting Ice Caps, this is a massive breach of the scientific method and...

Dubai is suffering from a catastrophic property slump. But more importantly,...

UCAT still accepting public comment

DIDO!

Secret Service admits lapse

Far more likely the gate was manned by far-right wing authoritarians....

Great column! Lets all sit back and share a good laugh about some of the...

First, the Constitution is flexible because there is a provision to modify it...

Sounds like you need to call the police and have some JW's arrested for...

Incredible finish, wait a minute, Illinois was just whistled for another foul.

Advertisements