Attorney general's office denies request for search warrant information

Published: Tuesday, Sept. 30, 2008 10:22 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
ROOSEVELT — The Utah Attorney General's Office has denied two open records requests from the Uintah Basin Standard seeking public information about a search warrant served on the Uintah School District office.

The district office was searched in July by criminal investigators with the attorney general's office. A source with knowledge of the search said authorities seized records and computers. The individual asked not to be identified because they are not authorized to speak to the media.

After learning about the search in late August, the Standard filed a request under the Government Records Access and Management Act seeking the location of the court where investigators filed their application for the school district search warrant. The request also sought the date that application was filed.

The attorney general's office denied the request, claiming that the information sought was protected under state law because it would disclose "an attorney's work product, including the mental impressions or legal theories of an attorney or other representative of a governmental entity concerning litigation."

The newspaper appealed the denial to chief deputy attorney general Kirk Torgensen, arguing that identifying the location where a public record is filed and the date it was filed could in no way reveal the information that investigators and prosecutors were seeking to protect.

Story continues below

Still, Torgensen denied the appeal. He advised the Standard that the information it sought was the subject of a court-issued secrecy order.

State law allows a prosecutor to ask a judge to put otherwise public records under a secrecy order during the course of an investigation. A judge can grant the request if a prosecutor can show that releasing the information would pose a substantial risk of harm to a person's safety; would cause a clearly unwarranted invasion of privacy or harm to a person's reputation; or would prove a serious impediment to the investigation.

"I don't think secrecy orders are that unusual in criminal investigations," said Jeff Hunt, a Salt Lake-based attorney who regularly represents Utah media outlets, including The Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret News. "I think what is very unusual is for the secrecy order to not even be on the docket of the court ... or to get a copy of it so you can challenge it. That's very unusual."

Hunt said one of the fundamental principals of the U.S. justice system is that the public has the right to at least know of a sealed court document or closed proceeding so it can be challenged.

"I don't know how revealing what court (a record is filed in) or the existence of the secrecy agreement could interfere with any criminal investigation," he said. "If they've executed the search warrant, then it's not a surprise for the people they've executed it on and it's not a surprise about what's been recovered."

Recent comments

"'I don't think secrecy orders are that unusual in criminal...

Lawyers don't keep their motions | Sept. 30, 2008 at 9:13 p.m.

This is extremely disturbing. The State has no real right to be...

bhparkman | Sept. 30, 2008 at 8:27 p.m.

It doesn't take much imagination for anyone to make a pretty good...

Curious George | Sept. 30, 2008 at 8:17 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Most of this story was valuable, but they could return the fee the agency...

Trade boozer, ak, miles, and suton or fez to the bobcats and bring in bell,...

Jazz get Thomas and Fernandez or Outlaw from portland. I'd prefer Rudy...

Kit, I hope you're intent was sarcasm. If it wasn't, the irony is pretty...

Farming for the needy

Dave comes from a very hard-working farm family where I live and work as an...

I can't wait for the 'Friendly'. I along with tens of fans look forward to...

Did you say name one team that would pay for his services? Well considering...

Teachers work 75% of the year, therefore their salaries are 75% of the...

Stop celebrity coverage

IF YOU STOPPED CELEBRITY COVERAGE FULLY, because of constant coverage of...

Although a die-hard Ute, I am a Fui fan. Good luck in Cinci!

Advertisements